Should the US give everybody Constitutional rights?

[zakmac12]

RESOLVED: United States government has a moral obligation to afford the same constitutional rights to all people on United States soil.

This is the oh-so-splendid, and terribly worded, Grand National topic for the National Catholic Forensics League.

Opinions? Do you take the negative (no) or the affirmative (yes) and why?

[President Camacho]

RESOLVED: United States government has a moral obligation to afford the same constitutional rights to all people on United States soil.

This is the oh-so-splendid, and terribly worded, Grand National topic for the National Catholic Forensics League.

Opinions? Do you take the negative (no) or the affirmative (yes) and why?

constitutional rights? what're those?

[Jesse the Great Tsar]

RESOLVED: United States government has a moral obligation to afford the same constitutional rights to all people on United States soil.

This is the oh-so-splendid, and terribly worded, Grand National topic for the National Catholic Forensics League.

Opinions? Do you take the negative (no) or the affirmative (yes) and why?

Depends if someone is offending someone else's rights.

[Mantis]

EVERYBODY EXCEPT THEM DAMN MEXICANS!

[Freet]

Every U.S. citizen should be protected under the constitution. Assuming of course that he hasn't squandered his rights due to imprisonment or whatever.

Just because you managed to sneak past the border patrol doesn't or shouldn't avail you of those rights.